Nepal’s leadership, in the less than even half-hearted attempt at tackling the coronavirus pandemic, has omitted one of the most important arsenal in their attack: a strategy. Ad hoc-ism has been the flavor of the last two months!
But then again what can one expect from a leadership that’s always been incompetent, ignorant, and arrogant, among many other things. They were no different in the aftermath of the biggest natural calamity to hit the country in living memory — the 2015 quakes.
We first heard about the virus five months ago. We had our first case four months ago. We went under lockdown on March 24, a decision taken just the day before, might I add. Every single time we approached the end of the lockdown period, it was renewed for an additional week or two. Following a few such renewals, we have been under lockdown for over 70 days now! What have we accomplished in that period?
I maintain a spreadsheet on Google Drive where I reproduce some of the official coronavirus-related figures the Ministry of Health and Population publish. The charts I have produced confirm the complete lack of strategy in confronting the pandemic. What I share below are some of the charts based on data since the lockdown.
Incidentally, if you are interested in updating yourself later, just return to the blog. All the charts are live, hence the unsusual appearance. They, therefore, update automatically when the spreadsheet is updated.
The following two charts are about testing. The first one (chart 1) shows the moving average for all tests (both polymerase chain reaction (PCR) tests and Rapid Diagnostic Test (RDT)) (blue); PCR test moving average (red); and PCR tests per million of population (green). I have not included data for RDT tests per million of population for two reasons. The first is that it’s NOT been a reliable test, and the second is that the government is NOT counting the positive results anyway (about which I’ll have more to say later).
The following one (chart 2) shows the daily PCR (blue) and RDT (red) tests conducted.
The above charts demonstrate how the Government of Nepal has had NO strategy to speak of when it comes to tackling the pandemic. I pointed this out the first time on May 21 in a tweet.
One (graphical) evidence gov. of #Nepal didn’t have a strategy to tackle d #coronavirus #pandemic: blue lines in the charts below.#MassTesting was part of d strategy employed by countries successfully containing d virus. #COVIDtesting #Covid19Nepal #LockdownNepal #COVID19 pic.twitter.com/VjrjxlzcIn
— Dorje Gurung (@Dorje_sDooing) May 21, 2020
The Government of Nepal “bought time” by imposing a lockdown when the cases of coronavirus was still small. It did NOT use it wisely at all though. It’s clear that when they initiated the lockdown on March 24, they had NO strategy — did I mention the decision was made the previous evening? — and has had NO strategy since either.
How do the charts show that? Simple. Just incremental and steady rise in the moving averages and tests performed per million population (chart 1) for one point at that. For another, the number of tests per day going up and down, and up and down over pretty much the entire lockdown period (chart 2).
The next two charts are about the cases of conronavirus infection. The following (chart 3) shows the number of cases of coronavirus infections.
Two things about the graph. Firstly, apparently, positive RDT results are NOT being reported. In other words, conducting RDT tests was NOT strategic in any way! When I discovered that I tweeted saying how that was crazy!
This is crazy!
RDT test results, though suspect, were carried out anyway.
Apparently, +ve results were NOT reported & contact tracing not conducted at all.
— Dorje Gurung (@Dorje_sDooing) May 14, 2020
I personally found confirmation for the contention — that they weren’t reporting the positive results — on May 17, and tweeted about it.
Two things from yesterday’s (5/16) situation report (no. #97).
1. Death of d 29-year old woman NOT reported (image 1)
2. d 31 RDT +ive cases of KTM municipality workers not reported either (image 2)
— Dorje Gurung (@Dorje_sDooing) May 17, 2020
What that means is that the number of cases shown in the graph is (much?) smaller than the real cases in the population.
Secondly, notice how it has started to curve upwards? That means we are now in the exponential growth rate of cases. I’ll have more to say about that below. Given that the numbers are under-estimated, we likely have been on the exponential growth rate phase for longer.
So what does the exponential growth rate mean? Well, it means that the number of cases keep shooting up rapidly and takes shorter and shorter time for them to double.
The graph below (chart 4) shows the doubling rates — the number of days it would take for the cases to double based on the last daily and weekly change.
The blue line charts the instantaneous doubling rate (rate calculated using cases from that and the previous day) and the red line charts the 3-day average doubling rate (the average over the last three days).
As you can see, the doubling rate has been around five days for several days now. Had the RDT results been included, these doubling rates would have been reached earlier.
So, in essence, all that the lockdown appears to have achieved — while bringing a lot pain and suffering on women, on the poorest, including the day laborers — is the postponement of the inevitable. With the easing of the lockdown, that curve (chart 3) is likely to continue sloping upwards, getting steeper by the day.
COVID-19 could potentially still cause a lot of deaths in spite of the numbers being low since the identification of the first case in January. One of the reasons for the low death rate, of course, is the lockdown. But, the complete lack of strategy and competency and, in its place, the abundance of arrogance and ignorance in those at the helms means that the whole situation turning into a major humanitarian crisis is a possibility.
My real worry, as expressed in a tweet some time ago is this:
My real worry now–after 4
months since 1st case & 2
months of #lockdown, & GoN
not having a real strategy to
tackle d #pandemic &
everything else it has thrown
at us–is that starvation, GoN
& ignorance might kill
LOT more ppl than d #virus.#Nepal
— Dorje Gurung (@Dorje_sDooing) May 18, 2020
What do you think?
June 18, 2020 Update
This chart shows the daily cases (blue) and three-day average (red).
The following chart shows the detection rate, that is, the daily number of cases per 1000 PCR tests.
The following shows the percentage of daily PCR tests that are positive.
This charts the daily PCR tests and the percent change each day from the previous one.